Most importantly, this update fixes a bug in nanobench that always
disabled performance counters on linux.
It also adds another sanitizer suppression that is caught in clang++ 12.
cdaab90662a54e331de0e49a89596bbb94a8ac45 Add test for addrman consistency check on restart with asmap (Jon Atack)
869f136816c6900ce84bc4b5a9c93c0deab85193 Add test for rpc addpeeraddress with "tried" argument (Jon Atack)
ef242f52137f2a79a739447251d7759bd4705be0 Allow passing "tried" to rpc addpeeraddress to call CAddrMan::Good() (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
This pull adds a `tried` argument to RPC addpeeraddress and a regression test for the recent addrman/asmap changes and issue.
PR #22697 introduced a reproducible bug in commit 181a1207 that fails addrman consistency checks and causes it to significantly lose peer entries when the `-asmap` configuration option is used.
The issue occurs upon bitcoind restart due to an initialization order change in `src/init.cpp` in that commit, whereby CAddrman asmap is set after deserializing `peers.dat`, rather than before.
Issue reported on the `#bitcoin-core-dev` IRC channel starting at https://www.erisian.com.au/bitcoin-core-dev/log-2021-08-23.html#l-263.
```
addrman lost 22813 new and 2 tried addresses due to collisions or invalid addresses
ADDRMAN CONSISTENCY CHECK FAILED!!! err=-17 bitcoind: ./addrman.h:707: void CAddrMan::Check() const: Assertion `false' failed. Aborted
```
How to reproduce:
- `git checkout 181a1207`, build, and launch bitcoind with the `-asmap` and `-checkaddrman=1` configuration options enabled
- restart bitcoind
- bitcoind aborts on the second call to the addrman consistency checks in `CAddrMan::Check()`
How to test this pull:
- `git checkout 181a1207`, cherry pick the first commit of this branch, build, git checkout this branch, run `test/functional/rpc_net.py`, which should pass, and then run `test/functional/feature_asmap.py`, which should fail with the following output:
```
AssertionError: Unexpected stderr bitcoind: ./addrman.h:739: void CAddrMan::Check() const: Assertion `false' failed.
```
ACKs for top commit:
jnewbery:
utACK cdaab90662a54e331de0e49a89596bbb94a8ac45
mzumsande:
re-ACK cdaab90662a54e331de0e49a89596bbb94a8ac45 (based on code review of diff to d586817)
vasild:
ACK cdaab90662a54e331de0e49a89596bbb94a8ac45
Tree-SHA512: 0251a18fea629b62486fc907d7ab0e96c6df6fadb9e4d62cff018bc681afb6ac31e0e7258809c0a88f91e4a36c4fb0b16ed294ce47ef30585217de89c3342399
c17f554fcc63e9e1f6ba64750df475d8a8d11f2e Fix BlockAssembler::AddToBlock, CTxMemPool::PrioritiseTransaction logging (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
This is a tale of two fees, er, fee rates... indeed, one is misdescribed as a fee, and the other is incorrectly called a fee rate.
From this review discussion: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/22689#discussion_r695866211 (thanks to John Newbery).
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK c17f554fcc63e9e1f6ba64750df475d8a8d11f2e
Tree-SHA512: 3d9df3209a72562c5f9bbf815923d5b089d04491b8d19caa2c04158c501b47ef01e47f1c32d89adcbaf3c6357329507f65b4bb2963214c3451bbfa61ac812530
9bdda50151dd808cbad094d457bf0ed7939a7c87 Enable TLS in links in documentation (Jeremy Rand)
Pull request description:
This PR enables TLS in several documentation links, which improves security.
ACKs for top commit:
fanquake:
ACK 9bdda50151dd808cbad094d457bf0ed7939a7c87
Tree-SHA512: 9d04d8771a9daf3c3b9914ff324e2eabfdf3ff5ae7f7dc92b84a1f3527010ceb860e73873a8f24d6051763eb472d9ea324ccbd6129a40318a520ca88c05f0586
57ce20307e604530f78ef4f0f8d9fb94f80ca81b fuzz: allow lower number of sources (Martin Zumsande)
acf656d540a82e6fc30421590305cfe295eabbb5 fuzz: Use public interface to fill addrman tried tables (Martin Zumsande)
eb2e113df13c7b1ede279878f5cbad877af49f8e addrman: Improve performance of Good (Martin Zumsande)
Pull request description:
Currently, `CAddrman::Good()` is rather slow because the process of moving an addr from new to tried involves looping over the new tables twice:
1) In `Good_()`, there is a loop searching for a new bucket the addr is currently in, but this information is never used except for aborting if it is not found anywhere (since [this commit](e6b343d880 (diff-49d1faa58beca1ee1509a247e0331bb91f8604e30a483a7b2dea813e6cea02e2R263)) it is no longer passed to `MakeTried`)
This is unnecessary because in a non-corrupted addrman, an address that is not in New must be either in Tried or not at all in addrman, both cases in which we'd return early in `Good_()` and never get to this point.
I removed this loop (and left a check for `nRefCount` as a belt-and-suspenders check).
2) In `MakeTried()`, which is called from `Good_()`, another loop removes all instances of this address from new. This can be spedup by stopping the search at `nRefCount==0`. Further reductions in `nRefCount` would only lead to an assert anyway.
Moreover, the search can be started at the bucket determined by the source of the addr for which `Good` was called, so that if it is present just once in New, no further buckets need to be checked.
While calls to `Good()` are not that frequent normally, the performance gain is clearly seen in the fuzz target `addman_serdeser`, where, because of the slowness in creating a decently filled addrman, a shortcut was created that would directly populate the tried tables by reaching into addrman's internals, bypassing `Good()` (#21129).
I removed this workaround in the second commit: Using `Good()` is still slower by a factor of 2 (down from a factor of ~60 before), but I think that this compensated by the advantages of not having to reach into the internal structures of addrman (see https://github.com/jnewbery/bitcoin/pull/18#issuecomment-775218676).
[Edit]: For benchmark results see https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/22974#issuecomment-919435266 and https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/22974#issuecomment-920445700 - the benchmark `AddrManGood` shows a significant speedup by a factor >100.
ACKs for top commit:
naumenkogs:
ACK 57ce20307e604530f78ef4f0f8d9fb94f80ca81b
jnewbery:
ACK 57ce20307e
laanwj:
Code review ACK 57ce20307e604530f78ef4f0f8d9fb94f80ca81b
theStack:
ACK 57ce20307e604530f78ef4f0f8d9fb94f80ca81b
vasild:
ACK 57ce20307e604530f78ef4f0f8d9fb94f80ca81b
Tree-SHA512: fb6dfc198f2e28bdbb41cef9709828f22d83b4be0e640a3155ca42e771b6f58466de1468f54d773e794f780a79113f9f7d522032e87fdd75bdc4d99330445198
330d3aa1a2c740dfa31bed3a6ed6b5f88e5426ad refactor: net: avoid duplicate map lookups to `mapLocalHost` (Sebastian Falbesoner)
Pull request description:
This simple refactoring PR aims to avoid duplicate lookups to `mapLocalHost`: instead of calling `count()` (to first find out whether a key is in the map) and then `operator[]` (to get the value to the passed key, or default-construct one if not found), use either
* `find()` and dereference the returned iterator (for simple lookups), see https://www.cplusplus.com/reference/map/map/find/
* `emplace()` and use the returned <iterator, inserted> pair (for lookups where a new element should be inserted if the key isn't found), see https://www.cplusplus.com/reference/map/map/emplace/
ACKs for top commit:
naumenkogs:
ACK 330d3aa1a2c740dfa31bed3a6ed6b5f88e5426ad
jonatack:
Code review ACK 330d3aa1a2c740dfa31bed3a6ed6b5f88e5426ad plus rebase to master + debug build
Tree-SHA512: d13da6a927ff561eee8ac6b093bf3586dfe31d6c94173a5a6d8f3698e0ee224fb394d3635155d5141c165da59d2c2c37260122eb4f2e8bcda3e8a29b901d213e
12313382e60c84f106127566d004c03384ca5abf doc: test: unittest segfault gdb (James O'Beirne)
Pull request description:
Quick note on how to get core dumps out of the unittests.
ACKs for top commit:
theStack:
ACK 12313382e60c84f106127566d004c03384ca5abf
Tree-SHA512: d749d9117f96af85f9053884c57df766ac1d29e57b2555d4fc63bd9dc29df47487954cee1c7cd78ee420ae1c9c7da7ddc9797b6c636ce7641eae20622eaa3fee
98cf19ca32785c991628324c313e01349c2986af wallet: refactor: avoid duplicate lookup on `mapValue["timesmart"]` (Sebastian Falbesoner)
973d8ba93d0fa00bed4569287e32696300036ab8 wallet: refactor: inline function WriteOrderPos() (Sebastian Falbesoner)
65ed198295e58cf1bc339aa17349b83490872f70 wallet: refactor: inline function ReadOrderPos() (Sebastian Falbesoner)
Pull request description:
The functions `ReadOrderPos` and `WriteOrderPos` have been introduced in commit 9c7722b7c5ce49130bd978b932f73b629ce5cebe in 2012. Since accounts have been removed in #13825 (commit c9c32e6b844fc79467b7e24c6c916142a0d08484), they are only called at one place in `CWalletTx::{Serialize,Unserialize}` and thus can be directly inlined instead. Additionally, this PR aims to avoids duplicate lookups on the map `mapValue` (affects keys "n" and "timesmart").
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK 98cf19ca32785c991628324c313e01349c2986af
achow101:
Code Review ACK 98cf19ca32785c991628324c313e01349c2986af
Tree-SHA512: 8af63c174c79e589bd713f04e8e40caba9f93ec2978c805427cac50d48049808a8c23ff5eea9ef589c9bd79fc66087f43ff5ab28e3cda51dd03f37c0164e2e4c
fa20f815a9cb438c5ab61e97a453612ddd8b21b5 Remove txindex migration code (MarcoFalke)
fae878603345854527c211ebb7d1967f12c8bb9d doc: Fix validation typo (MarcoFalke)
fab89006d656261770503e54fdd01ac9167bdd49 Add missing includes and forward declarations, remove unused ones (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
No supported version of Bitcoin Core used the legacy txindex, so all relevant nodes can be assumed to have upgraded. Thus, there is no need to keep this code any longer.
As a temporary courtesy, provide a one-time warning on how to free the disk space used by the legacy txindex.
Fixes#22615
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK fa20f815a9cb438c5ab61e97a453612ddd8b21b5
hebasto:
ACK fa20f815a9cb438c5ab61e97a453612ddd8b21b5, tested on Linux Mint 20.2 (x86_64).
Zero-1729:
crACK fa20f815a9cb438c5ab61e97a453612ddd8b21b5
theStack:
Approach ACK fa20f815a9cb438c5ab61e97a453612ddd8b21b5
Tree-SHA512: 68aa32d064d1e3932e6e382816a4b5de417bd7e82861fea1ee50660e8c397f4efeb88ae4ed54a8ad1952c3563eb0b8449d7ccf883c353cc4d4dc7e15c53d78e8
49d503aefa74f11e5d93432987fa3775ed82c979 doc: update -addrinfo in release-notes.md and tor.md (Jon Atack)
75ea9ecf11bfeb120c58dc6c62539021a94ef97c cli -addrinfo: drop torv2, torv3 becomes onion per GetNetworkName() (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
#22050 removed torv2 support from 22.0. For 23.0 and subsequent releases, we can probably remove torv2 from -addrinfo.
before
```
"addresses_known": {
"ipv4": 58305,
"ipv6": 5138,
"torv2": 0,
"torv3": 5441,
"i2p": 14,
"total": 68898
}
```
after
```
"addresses_known": {
"ipv4": 58305,
"ipv6": 5138,
"onion": 5441,
"i2p": 14,
"total": 68898
}
```
Per the naming of `netbase.{h, cpp}::GetNetworkName()`, torv3 becomes onion, which is what is printed in the output of getpeerinfo, getnetworkinfo and getnodeaddresses.
ACKs for top commit:
practicalswift:
cr ACK 49d503aefa74f11e5d93432987fa3775ed82c979
Zero-1729:
tACK 49d503aefa74f11e5d93432987fa3775ed82c979 🧉
klementtan:
Code review and tested ACK 49d503aefa74f11e5d93432987fa3775ed82c979
Tree-SHA512: bca52520d8b12c26f1c329d661b9e22c567954ed2af7d2a16d7669eae1a221eada20944f8b2f4e78e31a7190d5f3d3fbfd37509e5edf2d9a3747a0a8f4e375bb
350e034e64d175f3db4c85ddca42e76e279912f6 consensus: don't call GetBlockPos in ReadBlockFromDisk without lock (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
Commit ccd8ef65 "Reduce cs_main lock in ReadBlockFromDisk, only read GetBlockPos under the lock" in #11281 moved the cs_main lock from caller to `ReadBlockFromDisk()` for calling `CBlockIndex::GetBlockPos()`, but the second invocation doesn't have the lock, and IIUC there is no guarantee the compiler can know if state has changed.
Use the `blockPos` local variable instead, rename it to `block_pos`, and make it const.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK 350e034e64d175f3db4c85ddca42e76e279912f6
theStack:
Code-review ACK 350e034e64d175f3db4c85ddca42e76e279912f6
promag:
Code review ACK 350e034e64d175f3db4c85ddca42e76e279912f6.
Tree-SHA512: 0df0614ab1876885c85f7b53c604a759a29008da8027e95503b4726d2b820ec6d27546020c613337ff954406e01cb5d191978ba4a12124052fed6e1b0e9a226f
fa66a7d732f9fd60d72f22087f0d5aadf3064bfb p2p: Rename fBlocksOnly, Add test (MarcoFalke)
fac66d0a39cb0b4bc565b57087ba84dd932e9b6d test: Simplify p2p_blocksonly test with new miniwallet rescan_utxos method (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
`fBlocksOnly` has several issues:
* The name is confusing
* It is untested
Fix both.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK fa66a7d732f9fd60d72f22087f0d5aadf3064bfb
Tree-SHA512: 4218f455eeb37297f74603d7d44895288605844ae828a40dfb7a70215f1a058ac5ad945a22732f5ebcad3ad375d54ba360bea69ea79639a30d4c88b042448f0f
5008dd87b2c9a8eeee21f2a11367a7ada9c324ed doc: Remove stale comment for CPrivKey (Calvin Kim)
Pull request description:
Removes stale doc about `secure_allocator` being defined in `allocators.h`.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
ACK 5008dd87b2c9a8eeee21f2a11367a7ada9c324ed
theStack:
Code-review ACK 5008dd87b2c9a8eeee21f2a11367a7ada9c324ed
Tree-SHA512: eb65aff6db5b27d0db2b86f1d1dc6e066daccdaf00f7f9f95b5bee507167fcea2601316cdbd70da4ba32f1fab1e28e440a7e3cabd7b1a72c07dd20b1367361f0
317442525586ba9ff8b9af6c506b48f87cd8cd87 Cleanup headers after #20788 (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
This is a header cleanup after #20788.
ACKs for top commit:
vasild:
ACK 317442525586ba9ff8b9af6c506b48f87cd8cd87
Tree-SHA512: 1c21b1ba43841880625289174f10e5b333f6eb857f448e1e4114b1ecdf32a6044ec91c5987c1d66806c1d408a4e3d46569eb41d69a0acb8296601d7c203d9f1d
e4709c7b56612553fb7cbf16ef2d5099c5b732d0 Start using init makeNode, makeChain, etc methods (Russell Yanofsky)
Pull request description:
Use `interfaces::Init::make*` methods instead of `interfaces::Make*` functions, so interfaces can be constructed differently in different executable without having to change any code. (So for example `bitcoin-gui` can make an `interfaces::Node` pointer that communicates with a `bitcoin-node` subprocess, while `bitcoin-qt` can make an `interfaces::Node` pointer that controls node code in the same process.)
---
This PR is part of the [process separation project](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/projects/10). The commit was first part of larger PR #10102.
ACKs for top commit:
jamesob:
reACK e4709c7b56
achow101:
ACK e4709c7b56612553fb7cbf16ef2d5099c5b732d0
benthecarman:
utACK e4709c7b56612553fb7cbf16ef2d5099c5b732d0
Tree-SHA512: 580c1979dbb2ef444157c8e53041e70d15ddeee77e5cbdb34f70b6d228cc2d2fe3843825f172da84e506200c58f7e0932f7cd4c006bb5058c1f4e43259394834
This is done by removing an unnecessary loop in Good_() and looping
through the new tables in MakeTried() more efficiently, choosing a
starting value that allow us to stop early in typical cases.
Co-authored-by: John Newbery <john@johnnewbery.com>
5cc783f5f32ffd550d1b298fc2e9cf6c0439f9fe qt: ensure translator comments end in full stop (Jarol Rodriguez)
Pull request description:
This is a follow-up to #318 which addresses this [nit](https://github.com/bitcoin-core/gui/pull/318#discussion_r706856893) by addressing it globally.
This ensures that all GUI translator comments end in a full stop. If a comment does not end in a full stop, a translator may think that the rest of the comment is being cut off.
While here, add a colon to the word "see" for any comments touched which point to look at a link.
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 5cc783f5f32ffd550d1b298fc2e9cf6c0439f9fe, I have reviewed the code and it looks OK, I agree it can be merged.
shaavan:
Code Review ACK 5cc783f5f32ffd550d1b298fc2e9cf6c0439f9fe
Tree-SHA512: 67a1d56175c974e0af9b460fa44163f7ce139a7b81cfaf8ed2c0e7fb6d5120957c3135d96010aeb6229689468e36673fe9571b5a8c3e1c07e047aba1bd563444
9bd168bf5457c6fd9770769547d8757bf14813b0 qt: add missing tooltips to options menu settings (Jarol Rodriguez)
Pull request description:
This adds missing tooltips to the text of the `Size of database cache` and the `Number of script verification threads` settings.
All settings in the Options window will now have appropriate tooltip texts.
ACKs for top commit:
jonatack:
ACK 9bd168bf5457c6fd9770769547d8757bf14813b0 tested on Debian 5.10.46-4 (2021-08-03)
hebasto:
ACK 9bd168bf5457c6fd9770769547d8757bf14813b0, tested on Linux Mint 20.2 (Qt 5.12.8).
Tree-SHA512: d71946bfee33c624a8b79eafe514d2c902090a40bc25097be4c7da4a80270f53305002af1b27d5fd082a0f45f838e22036632f9445918c4b8898073b33c09c08
This ensures that all gui translator comments end in a full stop.
If a comment does not end in a full stop, a translator may think
that the rest of the comment is being cut off.
While here, add a colon to the word "see" for any comments
touched which point to look at a link.
Since accounts were removed in commit c9c32e6b844fc79467b7e24c6c916142a0d08484,
this function is only called at one place and thus can be as well inlined.
0b869df1c913839855148d728514c76ba7664092 qt: Add cancel button to configuration options popup (Shashwat)
Pull request description:
This PR renames the **OK** button to **Continue** and adds a **Cancel** button to the configuration options pop-up.
This feature will give the user an option to abort opening the configuration file if they want to. This is an essential helpful feature that was missing in the master branch.
In some windows managers such as Windows I3. The exit button at the top right corner is missing. So this feature becomes crucial there. And even when the exit button is there, it doesn't prevent the opening of the configuration file even when pressed.
Additionally, it will always be possible to close using Keyboard Shortcut. This PR helps accessibility for those who need to use a mouse.
<table>
<tr>
<td>Master
</td>
<td>PR
</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>
</td>
<td>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 0b869df1c913839855148d728514c76ba7664092, tested on Linux Mint 20.2 (Qt 5.12.8):
prayank23:
tACK 0b869df1c9
Tree-SHA512: c314e8b84064134f028f66f5015eb0f6ba33d5d4174c9ff49dcb5d2b577dce6019f59f9c7913393a415a323ea98c26febf5ca26e3e2102e7a1d31171e01937f1
3ec061d9da0c8742bd9dec94ffeb82a11d000aba qt: Add "Copy address" item to the context menu in the Peers table (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
Picking up #264
This adds a `Copy Address` context menu action to the `Peers Tab`.
Based on the first commit of PR #317 so that we can use `Qt::DisplayRole` in the `copyEntryData` function.
| Master | PR |
| ----------- | ----------- |
|  |  |
ACKs for top commit:
shaavan:
tACK 3ec061d9da0c8742bd9dec94ffeb82a11d000aba
luke-jr:
utACK 3ec061d9da0c8742bd9dec94ffeb82a11d000aba
hebasto:
ACK 3ec061d9da0c8742bd9dec94ffeb82a11d000aba, tested on Linux Mint 20.2 (Qt 5.12.8):
Tree-SHA512: be0d7324592aae3928fa3cc522294f17226419fe8cbe3587df12a36bd4fa9c81bead377b13051e950b9a3fcd290b273861e70d6c76b75cdf76eaf58224b834cd
The new name describes better what the bool does and also limits the confusion of the three different concepts:
* fBlocksOnly (This bool to skip tx invs)
* -blocksonly (A setting to ignore incoming txs)
* block-relay-only (A connection type in the block-relay-only P2P graph)
Since accounts were removed in commit c9c32e6b844fc79467b7e24c6c916142a0d08484,
this function is only called at one place and thus can be as well inlined. Also,
avoid a duplicate lookup by using the find() method and dereference, instead of
calling count() and operator[].
fa55c3dc1b4bbdc6a53bd11fa6c0b2ec6bbb64ae Raise InitError when peers.dat is invalid or corrupted (MarcoFalke)
fa4e2ccfd8ae96c381947285bef47cb39474ac89 Inline ReadPeerAddresses (MarcoFalke)
fa5aeec80c6cdca9ca027d80dff3b397911ff2c2 Move LoadAddrman from init to addrdb (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
peers.dat is silently erased when it can not be parsed or when it appears corrupted. Fix that by notifying the user. This might help in the following examples:
* The user provided the database, but picked the wrong one.
* A future version of Bitcoin Core wrote the file and it can't be read.
* The file was corrupted by a logic bug in Bitcoin Core.
* The file was corrupted by a disk failure.
ACKs for top commit:
jonatack:
Code review re-ACK fa55c3dc1b4bbdc6a53bd11fa6c0b2ec6bbb64ae per `git range-diff eb1f570 fa59c6d fa55c3` and verified the new tests fail on master, except "Check mocked addrman is valid", as expected
prayank23:
tACK fa55c3dc1b
vasild:
ACK fa55c3dc1b4bbdc6a53bd11fa6c0b2ec6bbb64ae
Tree-SHA512: 78264a78ee570a3c3262cf9c8542b5ffaffa5f52da1eef66c8c381f346989272967cfe1769c573502d9d7d3f7ad68c3ac3b2ec734185d2e4e7595b7122b14196
32748da0f47f7aa9fba78dfb29aa426b14f15624 whitespace fixups after move and scripted-diff (glozow)
fa47622e8dc66bec9ea690aec3f0999108d76dc9 scripted-diff: rename variables in policy/rbf (glozow)
ac761f0a23c9c469fa00885edf3d5c9ae7c6a2b3 MOVEONLY: fee checks (Rules 3 and 4) to policy/rbf (glozow)
9c2f9f89846264b503d5573341bb78cf609cbc5e MOVEONLY: check that fees > direct conflicts to policy/rbf (glozow)
3f033f01a6b0f7772ae1b21044903b8f4249ad08 MOVEONLY: check for disjoint conflicts and ancestors to policy/rbf (glozow)
7b60c02b7d5e2ab12288393d2258873ebb26d811 MOVEONLY: BIP125 Rule 2 to policy/rbf (glozow)
f8ad2a57c61d1e817e2445226688e03080fc8688 Make GetEntriesForConflicts return std::optional (glozow)
Pull request description:
This PR does not change behavior. It extracts the BIP125 logic into helper functions (and puts them in the policy/rbf* files). This enables three things - I think each one individually is pretty good:
- Implementation of package RBF (see #22290). I want it to be as close to BIP125 as possible so that it doesn't become a distinct fee-bumping mechanism. Doing these move-only commits first means the diff is mostly mechanical to review, and I just need to create a function that mirrors the single transaction validation.
- We will be able to isolate and test our RBF logic alone. Recently, there have been some discussions on discrepancies between our code and BIP125, as well as proposals for improving it. Generally, I think making this code more modular and de-bloating validation.cpp is probably a good idea.
- Witness Replacement (replacing same-txid-different-wtxid when the witness is significantly smaller and therefore higher feerate) in a BIP125-similar way. Hopefully it can just be implemented with calls to the rbf functions (i.e. `PaysForRBF`) and an edit to the relevant mempool entries.
ACKs for top commit:
mjdietzx:
ACK 32748da0f47f7aa9fba78dfb29aa426b14f15624
theStack:
Code-review ACK 32748da0f47f7aa9fba78dfb29aa426b14f15624 📐
MarcoFalke:
review ACK 32748da0f47f7aa9fba78dfb29aa426b14f15624 🦇
Tree-SHA512: d89985c8b4b42b54861018deb89468e04968c85a3fb1113bbcb2eb2609577bc4fd9bf254593b5bd0e7ab059a0fa8192d1a903b00f77e6f120c7a80488ffcbfc0
853c4edb70f897a6a7165abaea4a303d7d448721 [net] Remove asmap argument from CNode::CopyStats() (John Newbery)
9fd5618610e91e3949536c5122cf31eb58c9aa6b [asmap] Make DecodeAsmap() a utility function (John Newbery)
bfdf4ef334a16ef6108a658bf4f8514754128c18 [asmap] Remove SanityCheckASMap() from netaddress (John Newbery)
07a9eccb60485e71494664cc2b1964ae06a3dcf0 [net] Remove CConnman::Options.m_asmap (John Newbery)
Pull request description:
These small cleanups to the asmap code are the first 4 commits from #22910. They're minor improvements that are independently useful whether or not 22910 is merged.
ACKs for top commit:
naumenkogs:
ACK 853c4edb70f897a6a7165abaea4a303d7d448721
theStack:
Concept and code-review ACK 853c4edb70f897a6a7165abaea4a303d7d448721 🗺️
fanquake:
ACK 853c4edb70f897a6a7165abaea4a303d7d448721
Tree-SHA512: 64783743182592ac165df6ff8d18870b63861e9204ed722c207fca6938687aac43232a5ac4d8228cf8b92130ab0349de1b410a2467bb5a9d60dd9a7221b3b85b
At this point, or minimum required glibc is implicitly 2.18, due to
thread_local support being enabled by default. However, users can
disable thread_local support to maintain 2.17 ccompat for now, which is
currently done in the Guix build.
f530202353a4f8bb444966559aa15681ab3cebc6 Make unexpected time type in BCLog::LogMsg() a compile-time error (Martin Ankerl)
bddae7e7ff7bb5931ed807acaef7336f2ee98476 Add util/types.h with ALWAYS_FALSE template (MarcoFalke)
498b323425d960274c40472a6a847afc1982201d log, timer: improve BCLog::LogMsg() (Jon Atack)
8d2f847ed913f15677ae978a412015ac844ffceb sync: inline lock contention logging macro to fix time duration (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
Follow-up to #22736.
The first commit addresses the issue identified and reported by Martin Ankerl in https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/22736#discussion_r703019629 to fix the lock contention duration reporting.
The next three commits make improvements to the timer code in `BCLog::LogMsg()` and add `util/types.h` with an `ALWAYS_FALSE` template, that springboard from https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/22736#discussion_r702747920 by Marco Falke.
ACKs for top commit:
martinus:
re-ACK f530202353a4f8bb444966559aa15681ab3cebc6. I ran a fully synced node for about a day. My node was mostly idle though so not much was going on. I [wrote a little script](https://github.com/martinus/bitcoin-stuff/blob/main/scripts/parse-debuglog-contention-single.rb) to parse the `debug.log` and summarize the output to see if anything interesting was going on, here is the result:
theStack:
ACK f530202353a4f8bb444966559aa15681ab3cebc6
Tree-SHA512: 37d093eac5590e1b5846ab5994d0950d71e131177d1afe4a5f7fcd614270f977e0ea117e7af788e9a74ddcccab35b42ec8fa4db3a3378940d4988df7d21cdaaa
